About Me


  • I'm like, smart.

Read Me

Stalk Me

Blog powered by TypePad

« Rape Can Be Boring | Main | There's No Such Thing as a "Bad Feminist" »

Comments

Brooke

Well, I didn't see what was so terrible about what you said. I feel sorry for Moe that she kinda makes excuses for the guy who raped her.

Fake Name

So I finally saw the entire video and it makes the whole hoopla seem like a HUGE media (Lizz) creation. I expected to see you guys slurring while calling rape victims "nappy-headed hoes" based off the comments on HuffPo, Jezebel, Jess, and other blogs. Some of the jokes fell flat, but they weren't mean spirited. Maybe I'm just giving you the benefit of the doubt b/c I've read your stuff, but it wasn't nearly as bad as advertised.

Fake Name

@Slut Machine

Did you ever comment about this over on Jezebel? The thread was so huge, I never got through all the comments.

beatty

Booooring. Are we still on this?

Putting it into "context" doesn't really help the few things that were said that were horribly out of line.

But who cares, you can say what you want.... lets just not dwell. It's o-v-e-r.

ralph

Reading this, it is hard to believe you are even slightly famous.

We clearly have no standards.

J

Wait...THIS is what people were getting so frigging upset about?!
God, people take themselves way too seriously.

slut machine

no, i didn't comment about it because i wasn't really allowed to. and because i didn't want to get distracted during the work day and get sucked into a comment war. i'm not still focusing on this, but i'm kinda pissed that lizz took EVERYTHING that we said out of context and sensationalized it to promote her shitty theater show. she's kinda the rapist in the situation, in that she plied us with booze and then took advantage of us. especially, when during the interview, she made comments like this one:

"When we were in college, we used to fuck guys to help us move. The night before moving, we would go out and get drunk, and then we’d fuck guys, and then the next morning we’d be like, ‘Oh, we’re moving, and we just fucked you,’ and they always helped!"

i remember being like, "what the fuck is this lady talking about?" but i politely laughed, because i was on her show and all.

k

Lizz: You could get raped.
Tracie: But I wouldn't.
Moe: That's happened, too, but you live through that, you know.
Lizz: Sometimes you don't.
Moe: I mean, that's true if they have weapons.
Tracie: But when I bring someone home, I want to fuck them, I'm not going to bring someone home and be like, "No, not tonight."
Hunh. I'm pretty confused about this part:
Lizz: Wait, wait, hold on a second, that's just not how rape works, though. If you bring a guy home and want to fuck him and he goes, "Guess what, I'm a psycho and now that I'm licking your face I want to kill you."

What does that have to do with rape? Sounds to me like she's describing murder, which is a bit different, yes? Bringing a guy home who you want to fuck who then turns out to be a murderer is a little different than a "rapist", when he was going to get laid anyway. WTF, Lizz.

kdiddy

this is the first time that I've actually had a good look at the conversation (haven't had a good time to watch the video). I'm honestly now quite flabbergasted that you and Moe were attacked the way you were. perhaps your biggest crimes were not being sober (but then how were you to know that you would need to be on your best, most sober feminist game?), you weren't dutifully reverent (fuck that), and you spoke casually (gasp!). and honestly, shame on Lizz for victim-blaming Moe the way she did. it really seems to go against a lot of what she said and purports to believe.
all this is to say that I think I get where you're coming from and I'm sorry that you two got so lambasted. It sucks. and also, you're awesome. you both make a lot of really excellent points. all of this pearl-clutching needs to stop.

lempha

i am so confused right now. how was that a media shitstorm? cause, you know, i found it interesting, intriguing, honest. i don't know what, exactly, lizz was expecting if not that. and the jokes /were/ funny.

Seyour

For such a strong ballsy woman you play victim an awful lot.

Take a little responsiblity for your back-firing jokes and your shallow grasp of feminisim.

It's not hateration, its education.

You ultimately rock but would do so harder if you actually owned your actions and the fallout that ocassionally ensues from time to time. The 'they just don't get me' defence is the reserve of whiny teenagers. A bad ass like yourself need not apply that particular ointment.

ameobalike

I'm in the same boat as kdiddy... I followed the drama on Jezebel but couldn't watch the video 'cause I do all my internet surfing at work. This is my first exposure to what actually went down and I have to say, WTF? It's almost like people blew up at you because they'd been looking for a reason to all along. You guys are way better spoken than I imagined was the case given the dramatic way in which it was edited down/people were attacking you. I really don't see anything wrong with what was said on your end.

ameobalike

As for people who say she needs to own up to her actions... what actions are you talking about? Speaking openly and candidly? Sharing her opinions? Isn't that why we read this blog? Isn't that why you'd want to go see her speak in person? Seems like she owns up to it pretty well.

Lizzie

I didnt think this was a big deal then or now. Lizz exploiting it for her own gain was par for the course because of how much free self promotion it bought her. So whatever to that. My only WTF moment came with the comment explosion on Jezebel where people were like "you didnt give us a forum to discuss this so what did you think would happen. we need to heal!" and then it devolved from there to the point where people were saying things to the effect of "Tracie thinks she is so cool because she has bangs." I just could not wrap my mind around how people could possibly care so much about this. I hope it didnt get you down too much.

youguysarefeminists?

I'm glad to see that you finally put this whole transcript up. I think a lot of people only saw the unflattering edits and read isolated quotes. Did you guys come off like Rhodes Scholars? No. But did you deserve to be crucified by Lizz Cunstead and her self righteous feminist legions? No. At the very least I guess you could consider it flattering that Lizz thought she could use you and Moe to jump start her career that's sagging like her tits.

Amy

"The thing that I can do is I can just write... I only write what I know. That's what I do best. And the only thing that I can do is write about my experiences and if women can relate to that, then I feel like that's great and they... and we can all share those experiences. But I feel like in the same way that, like, Moe knows shit about China, I don't know shit about China. I wouldn't write about that. I don't know shit about rape, and so I don't really want to write about that because, like, in a way that I might be like "This is how you protect yourself," like, I've taken self-defense courses and stuff and that's never been something that I've had to encounter, so, I feel like I really write from my own experiences, and so that's really all I can go by. As far as writing about the truth and whatever."

That part stuck out to me from the beginning. Just keep writing your truth, Tracie, and this shitstorm will blow over. I still don't see what you or Moe did wrong; in fact, I thought exactly what you did about Lizz's position in this situation being parallel to that of a rapist. I actually commented to your last post suggesting that, expecting people to flip their shit. Because you know what? No matter what you say about rape-- unless it's the obvious "well, rape is horrible" which we can all pretty much agree with--someone is going to flip their shit.

But yeah... keep writing, keep sharing with us. Don't let the bullshit get you down. You've always been so candid about everything on this blog and on Jezebel, and that is why so many people love your writing. I hope you will get back to sharing your experiences with us soon. (The first time I came upon this blog, I was like, "Wow! She actually addresses bleeding on the sheets! She doesn't act like it's some kind of cardinal sin, either! I like this woman!")

Stay who you are. You don't need to defend yourself any further. You didn't do anything wrong.

Sammi

*This* is why everyone was freaking out?

The only thing in the conversation that really offended me was L's implication that adult women need to model themselves after someone. I didn't buy Uggs when they were trendy and I'm not going to do ecstasy or two dudes at once just because I love your blog.

Forget the haters and don't (don't don't!) start getting mousy about what you say. Your candidness is what makes you so badass. Your shamelessness is contagious - and if women need anything, it's to lose their shame so they can (Oh God, so corny) just be themselves.

("Yeah, I have weird hair on my nipples. What of it?")

Mad hearts!

tb

I have to agree that I can't believe this is what people got their panties in a bunch about.

If anything they should be pissed that you had a lame interviewer who contradicted herself (equating sexual freedom with more rape and then clarifying that that was not what she meant)

sam

yeah, um, no way dude. that lizz winstead is a predator. and kind of a nut. party foul.

kira

I tried to watch the whole video and couldn't, it was just too painfully awkward.

You and Moe were so drunk as to be incomprehensible (which doesn't come though in the transcript).

Regardless of what you said, how you said it was completely unprofessional. I suggest all of the commenters who've said "ooh, I never actually bothered to watch the interview in question, it's TOTALLY not that bad!" go check out the video.

Comedy or not, showing up to speak somewhere (especially if people are paying to here you) plastered is immature. Adults own up to their actions. They don't try to justify them by whining about how their internet went out or how they are trying to quit smoking or how they got drunk (but it somehow wasn't their fault?!).

You and Moe acted like bratty 15 year old girls who've just had their first frat party beer. It's not cute when you're 15, and it isn't cute when you're 30.

You should stop whining about how Lizz was "kinda the rapist in the situation," apologize for everyone who paid to see your drunk ass, and be happy you still have your job.

slut machine

hey kira, why don't you shut the fuck up? how fucking DARE you say that i came off bad because i was drunk? that's like finding fault with me because i was "unladylike." i don't think i misrepresented myself at all. i thought i was going there to drunkenly (as per the title of the show, and the request of the producers who were TELLING us to get loaded before hand, making sure we were double fisting for a full hour before we went on) discuss tyra banks. and then it turned into this. i am not apologetic of anything i said or how i acted. i just want to be as honest as possible in everything that i do. and i felt like a lot of dishonest shit went down with all of this, mostly on winstead's part. especially after she sought me out right after the show, smiled in my face, shook my hand, and told me i was great.

kira

If you want to be as honest as possible, then you should just post the actual video.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=3878564552149113212&hl=en

JES

The part about the Ugg boots at the end is the best.

Also, fuck Lizz for making Moe feel like a bad person for not reporting her rape. She just blamed Moe for other girls getting raped. She actually put the onus of those girls getting raped on Moe instead of where it belong (i.e. on the rapist). HOW THE FUCK IS THAT OKAY?

"Lizz: I think that's where your mistake was."
\
What? what mistake? Moe didn't make a mistake, Moe was raped, and had the only authentic experience she could have. She didn't "make a mistake". SO FUCKED UP.

Lizz's most dread conversation

Lizz: "Hi, I'm Lizz, and I created THE DAILY SHOW."

Person: "OMG! I love that show! What is Jon Stewart like?"

Lizz: (icily) "No I left before Stewart came on the show.

Person: Oh....ah. So what, uh, is uh, that guy, what's his name? What's he like? See I don't know because I never watched the show before Stewart because it WASN'T FUNNY.

kat

i think that giggling should be written into the transcript. it might clear things up just a tad. all in all, the whole concept of this show was to be comedic, and the audience laughed quite a bit, so i'm missing the whole freak-out somewhere.

Caitlin

Kira - 1) I WISH I could be this intelligent drunk and 2) I wish I was that intelligent at 15. "Just because I am a woman with a vagina I am not automatically classified as a potential rape victim." - this is SO true, and I think it is an essential idea that got fully pushed aside.

MOREOVER - What the fuck is up with Lizz's rant about the HRC needing to clarify that they support gay rights? What does she think Human Rights SHOULD mean? I guess there's a slight possibility she was being ironic, but if she wasn't that was one load of bullshit drivel.

Jesus, Narcissism.

you bolded your own statements.

slut machine

yeah, on my own fucking website.

mariaaaaa

"Moe: No offense to the retards."

HAHAHAHAHA! For some reason that line made me laugh.

"Lizz: That was your mistake"

That line made me gasp. Way to blame a 19 year old. That's so understanding of you.

As someone who will be seeing the sands of my thirties run out soon, I take umbrage at the assumption that the olds can't drive in the internets! Don't assume sister! (Said from someone who refuses to Facebook, Twitter, etc. and who realizes her obsolence is indeed possibly imminent.) (Is obsolence even a word?)

schlegs84

Kira,

1) Everything that SM said.
2) What is more like a 15 year old girl? Getting drunk before a comedy show and having it go haywire or going to someone's blog to write catty comments about them?

Your mind is clearly made up, why are you still here? Go somewhere else! Last I checked people don't come to a site titled "One D at a Time" for lectures on sobriety and professionalism.

kira

schlegs84-

Because I used to like SM. I thought she was witty and funny and I consistently enjoyed reading her stuff here and on Jezebel.

That said, I thought she and Moe fucked up on Shoot the Messenger. I didn't say anything about it, 'cause, shit, everyone has bad days and fucks up.

However, it's been more than a week and SM keeps making excuses for her behavior and blaming the producers and Lizz and talking shit.

So yeah, I guess it was wrong of me to say that. Shit, I'd better go fuck myself, or something, for having an opinion on someones blog. I didn't know that these comments were only for the people who thing SM is perfect. My mistake.

kira

thing=think

blergh

This dead horse. Is a bloody red pulp.

Chelsie

This blog used to be interesting. What happened? For the love of God, talk about something else. We get it. You feel "exploited". Move on or stop writing.

mc

Even from the very beginning, when I read Winstead's original page about how 'disappointed' she was in you&Moe, it all seemed so suspicious. The idea that you guys are writing as role models, even when it first was suggested, just seemed ridiculous--are women supposed to be so desperate for guidance that they will listen to someone on the internet before they examine their own inclinations&impulses? Feminism, to me, is about making choices based on your wants, desires, and needs rather than what society expects of you as a woman--to, for example, be free from being guilted into becoming a 'compassionate caregiver' just because we are female. You're an individual before you're female, ideally. And it just seems like Winstead wants to paint women as this large, sweeping group of vulnerable sheep who will buy uggs and turn every media personality into a role model. She wants women to be female before they are individuals, and then to be guided (as a group) into some sort of safer, utopian world by constantly being vigilant and scared. I think it is a little hypocritical for her to claim that you are wrong for not respecting the old guard, but then ALSO wrong for taking full advantage of increased sexual freedom. I just don't think we should hold anyone to our personal standards; give people information and let them make their own choices and then support them in those decisions. You can't provide freedom and then back out & revoke it when you don't like the decisions freed people make. And I think your blog and Jezebel should be--and mostly are--about just telling the truth, owning your flaws, and making it a little easier for the private self and public self to match up. Doing away with shame and self-hatred and repression is the only way to counteract these fucked up social problems. I really believe this. If we weren't so fucking puritanical, if we didn't try so hard to get rid of the impulses we all have because of human nature, then we could be happy with who we are, and we wouldn't want to fucking change everyone around us all the time so that we all fit this image of what a 'better' humanity would look like. You can't make people better. You can't get rid of abortion. You have to be realistic, and work with what we have--which is human nature. So people should stop feeling bad about their 'dirty' impulses and just live them publicly. And you do that, and I respect that so much. You make it easier for other people to stop hating themselves so much for their impulses and decisions--which society tells them are so dirty and wanton and 'wrong,' even though many, many people have the desires.

BEANER

"she plied us with booze and then took advantage of us." -SM


i thought you liked that-? or is it just not convenient here?

blah

"You and Moe were so drunk as to be incomprehensible (which doesn't come though in the transcript)."
yeah, if by incomprehensible you mean interrupted by interviewer when attempting to a. answer said interviewer's questions b. finish a thought previously interrupted by interviewer c. reiterate comment horribly misinterpreted by interviewer...

"Regardless of what you said, how you said it was completely unprofessional."
sounds like my ex-boyfriend's reasoning. "Well maybe you did defend what you believe in, but I don't like your shoes"

Alyssa

How sick that Lizz would attempt to berate Moe for not reporting her rape! That shit is personal. I don't know the circumstances of Moe's date rape, but having just spent four years at a university in which the frat culture made it humiliating and difficult for rape victims to come out, I am seriously appalled. It sickens me how callous Lizz could be, not only judging another woman's course of action post-rape, but actually blaming her for future rapes--may as well blame her for her own rape, Lizz, because of looks/dress/etc.

That said, stay strong Tracie, and keep on doing your thing. You're the only reason I stop by Jezebel anymore.

randomvoyeur

"Your mind is clearly made up, why are you still here? Go somewhere else! Last I checked people don't come to a site titled "One D at a Time" for lectures on sobriety and professionalism."

Ex-fuckin-actly. Well put

Hannah

Shame on Lizz, and shame on anyone that makes the argument that you're a role model and should behave as such. While I do think that you're an inspiring person, you don't dictate my morals for me. Some of the fun of being a reader here is getting to see a lifestyle that I can't quite live out myself.

And honestly? You were funny. Yes, maybe I did cringe when I heard the rape talk, but in the same way I do when I hear "dead baby" jokes. It's funny because it hits a nerve.

We all know you don't advocate rape. We all know you don't blame women for it. Can we please get past this?

You were drunk. Were I held accountable for every drunken rant I've spewed... it wouldn't be pretty.

JewBoy

Life is not black and white. Blame, regret, and remorse are spread among many, but who will step up? SM, time to STEP UP. Will you - CAN you admit SOME remorse, apologize for YOUR (not ALL) sh*t in this storm and be the bigger fuckin person. Passing it ALL off makes you seem FIVE years old, not fifteen.

You can't say no to a producer who offers you a drink or five? what kind of a woman are you? STEP UP

But hell, at least there's something to read on here again!

Sara

It is your website so you can bold whatever you please.

It's pretty clear that Lizz Winstead is a nasty bitch. The kind of "feminist" that hates women. They are the WORST and leave with such an icky feeling after you are subjected to their hostile undertones without understanding if you're picking up on something, if they're crazy, or if you're crazy because those type of women will always find something to throw back in your face. Make it seem like you started it, when they are the ones that manipulated the shit-storm in the first place. That is abusive behavior; Dare I say borderline emotional-gasp-date rape. You think you can trust someone, and they turn around and betray you to the entire internet. I don't blame you for being upset. I would be.

Keep on sister. You're hot.

erik

hahaha captain save a ho. that is my new away message, replacing paula abdul's i was a lakers girl, quietly making demo tapes. honestly, ditto, to what everyone else is saying: keep on. lizz sounded more hostile than not, and i only read the first half.

erik

hahaha captain save a ho. that is my new away message, replacing paula abdul's i was a lakers girl, quietly making demo tapes. honestly, ditto, to what everyone else is saying: keep on. lizz sounded more hostile than not, and i only read the first half.

red_sparkle

What I don't get about this Kira girl is why she thinks she is the SM police. Seriously? Like, boo hoo, you some how hurt her feelings? Why is this so personal? Common girlfriend, enroll yourself in a community College somewhere and get a life. I'd like to know who died and left Ki-Ki in charge of the internet? I'm glad I am all the way over here in Seattle with Bill Gates and Jeff Bezos. Sheesh. Sounds like this girl is seriously bitter for some apparent reason. Probably a) a bad dye job/over sized forehead or b) her boyfriend dumped her for a queen and she secretly hates gays. Either way, I keep reading her comments and thinking if I had a cock I wouldn't mind leaving a nice imprint on the side of her forehead or for that matter, trick her into choking on it.

And just for the record, I never comment on blogs, BUT today I sent my father's real estate agent (and I don't speak to my father) the following TEXT on accident: "My period is over so lets get drunk and screw." Thinking it was my husband, but I was in such a hurry I typed the wrong name into my blackberry. Oh well. Everyone makes mistakes, all women, no matter how high up or how much money they make. Now whether or not you think this whole thing is a mistake, well that's your right to interpret. But, I seriously think anyone who didn't get the satire of the most recent New Yorker isn't going to understand what goes behind the scenes in any given situation and therefore it is useless to think they can infer what's going on in this situation.

Anywayz...POT Psychology is the only way to solve problems. Lets send Lizzie some Yukon "Gold" Brownies before her next show and see how she makes out. I'll make sure their addressed from Microsoft so she actually eats them. =]

Kate

Tracie, I was sort of reluctant to get into this whole things, and I absolutely couldn't watch the video cause Moe was too drunk and Lizz's voice makes me want to claw my eyes out... plus, I kind of feel like my interest in your goings on is a little weird (but that's mostly because I think your friends and my friends combined would be like the new Team America) and that I'd get all disappointed in you or whatever if there was any actual shit to get bummed out over...

ANYWAY, I'm so glad you posted this transcript because
what. the. fuck.
Lizz says just as much questionable shit!

And THIS:
"I don't know what that means. That's like whenever there are people from the HRC on the street and they're like, "Do you believe in gay rights? And I'm like "Your organization doesn't have gay rights in the title." Like, if you're for gay rights that your organization should say gay rights in the title. And your for human rights and you voted for Canada to vote for the war and against women's issues and I hate that. Like identify for what you are. It bugs me. It's like you have to look outside yourself, you know, you're called the Human Rights Campaign and you're a gay rights organization and you don't have gay in the title, why don't you, it fucking freaks me out. I just think it's bizarre. Yeah, but, so, the old guard..."

Comes out of nowhere! Woman is crazy. I mean, it wasn't the best interviwe ever and I wish Moe had made what I feel are the REALLY good, interesting points about date rape (the way men are socialized often being the greater factor in a lot of physically non-violent date rape, and such) but overall, you definitely painted a pretty decent picture of what I like about Jezebel and about you and Moe in particular.

Also, I understand why you keep posting here about it. You didn't really get the change to rebut all the CRAZY shit on Jezebel and here at least you can feel like you were able to complete a thought - unlike in the interview, ha ha.

I know you'll get past this gross debacle. Please please keep it up.

T

I can't believe THIS is what caused all that crap at Jezebel and with the Lizzie person. It was made to be way more scandalous or offensive or whatever it was supposed to be, when it is not at all. I agree with the person who thinks Lizzie just comes across as hostile, she seems so self-righteous. Like she has never made a mistake before, if you can even call Moe's date rape choice that. Ugh, there isn't a black and white answer to everything. I don't understand why she didn't grasp that.

Don't let the haters get you down SM. I look forward to all of your posts on Jezebel and this blog. Its your opinions and you should stick to them, or change them. It is your prerogative.

Sparker_Pants

I want to give Moe a hug.

I commend you for being as honest as possible, and I'm sorry you've had to deal with this whole ordeal- even if its "par for the course" when writing online as "everyone" claims, that doesn't make it any easier to deal with when it's happening to you, no matter the scale.

Chin up, hotstuff! (Also please enjoy the archaic use of the term "chin up!")

the millionizer

just a hug. lizz was totally out of line. not more i can say. i watched the video and she made me want to rip my ovaries out and stick them in my ears. you guys rocked.

ramonaquimby

"oooooooh how i miss/ substituting the conclusion to confrontation with a kiss ..."

i think the solution to this whole shitstorm is for you to make out more. i think what you need now is a good old fashion sex scandal to help wash out the bad taste of moldy feminisms this witch hunt (slut hunt?) must have left in your mouth.

some of these folks are rabid, yo.

Ventura

I guess my reaction is What is your point here Tracie? Sure you were ambushed, but more to the point, you were completely taken advantage of -- and yeah it is a kind of an assault. Lizz is using you to generate her own buzz. I really doubt she gives a flying fuck about whether you or Moe were or weren't raped or whether you or Moe are "suitable" role models to young women today. She needs to make herself relevant. It's kind of like the fat, ugly girl in school who comes up to the cool kids, who've never really noticed her at all and bear her no ill will, actually, and starts screaming about how mean they are. She needs to be noticed and this is the only way she can figure out, by forcing herself into the coveted spotlight of others. So forget Lizz, she's not worth worrying about. But perhaps this is a good opportunity to sit back and decide what it is you really ARE trying to say with your dick schtick. You're not the first young woman to rebel by being sexually depraved. Hell, Madonna was the master of sexual provocation up until she became Grande Dame Madge and had to clean up her act because it gets kind of embarassing for women to be so sexually desperate after a certain age. People don't like to read about older wrinkly saggy-titted women having sex anyway. I hate to say it but your writing reminds me a lot of the Happy Hooker from the early 70s -- at least the shocking sexual aspects of it. So what, exactly, do you have to add to the ongoing discussion Tracie? Despite your cavalier attitude, it's obvious your writing is really important to you. You have a great voice and a decent talent. I believe you are a feminist, although I really don't believe that hypersexuality and alcoholism are particularly feminist, but whatevs, if that's your thing, it's your thing. I just wonder at the end of the day, what is your point going to be in all of this?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment